Norway custody row: Mother was depressed, needed help with children, says report – India

20 feb 2012

Norway custody row: Mother was depressed, needed help with children, says report


Dr Sanjay Kumar Cardiac Cardiothoracic Heart Surgeon India

Dr Sanjay Kumar Cardiac Cardiothoracic Heart Surgeon India


Oslo:  Add one to the list of an average Indian mother’s worst nightmares. Sagarika Bhattacharya’s two toddlers were taken away from her because, among other things, a Norwegian court noted that she locked the door when cooking or bathing and force-fed the children.

NDTV has accessed that court order, a confidential report of November last year, that supported a recommendation that the children of Anurup and Sagarika Bhattacharyya should be put in a foster home as the parents were unfit to bring them up. Three-year-old Abhigyan and one-year-old Aishwarya have been in a foster home for the last 10 months. They were taken away by the child welfare service in Stavenger, Norway, and the court found reason not to re-unite them with their parents because kindergarten staff and child welfare professionals who were in their home to assist them, said Sagarika was clinically depressed and needed help with the children. Sagarika says she has not been tested medically before being termed clinically depressed.

The court also found her attitude towards the children “erratic”. It noted that son Abhigyan was diagnosed with attachment disorder; the boy, the court said, reacted if the mother raised her hand, as though she intended to hit him and concluded that he had either been hit before or had seen physical violence between the parents. It also criticised Sagarika for describing Abhigyan as arrogant and for leaving infant Aishwarya “in dangerous situations when changing diapers.”

Her world tossed asunder, Sagarika is still trying to come to terms with the court ruling that an unknown foster family is better qualified to bring up her children. “Abhigyan is still banging his head on the ground and spitting on people’s faces. So it is proved that he is not really improving a lot,” she said after meeting her children last week.

Father Anurup, a Geologist, got his share of blame from the court; the observations would make the average Indian father reassess his work-life balance. The court has objected to his “prioritising work” and for enrolling in a Norwegian language course and taking driving lessons instead of spending more time at home. Sagarika was “rigid”, the court said, for not insisting that the husband stay more at home and help. It found Anurup “rigid” because he did not encourage the children’s grandparents to come to Norway. It even found Aishwarya, then barely six months old, a “rigid and silent child.”

The Bhatacharyas have, through their months of ordeal, said that “cultural misunderstandings” caused this tale of separation. The Norwegian authorities have categorically denied that cultural differences have played a role in their decision to take the children away. Yet, the court noted as part of its case against the parents that they had an arranged marriage; commonplace in India, not largely understood in the West.

And the court takes umbrage at Anurup Bhattacharya saying that going back to India is the solution for the beleaguered family.

Last week, the parents met their children for a few hours watched closely by officials of Norway’s child welfare services. They can only meet the children once every three months. A plea by Anurup’s brother Arunabhas Bhattacharya that he be given custody of the children is yet to considered by the Norwegian authorities, which agreed to even look at that option only at the intervention of the Indian government.

The uncle, a bachelor and a dentist by vocation, has left his practice in West Bengal to live in Stavenger till he gets custody. He is being made to attend regular sessions with the welfare service and psychologists. He needs to prove to the Norwegian authorities that the upbringing of the two children will “meet with their needs.”
In India, the grandparents plan a sit-in in protest against the two children being kept away from the family.

About Surgeon Sanjay Kumar

Surgeon Sanjay kumar Cardiothoracic Cardiac Heart Surgery Dr Surgeon
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s